Negligent Valuation Claim Fails on Causation: ICG v Colliers (2026) EWHC 2927 (BP) Finds a £23.75m Shopping Centre Valuation Negligent but Awards Nothing (November 2026)

A valuation can be 25% too high, be found negligent by a High Court judge, and still cost the valuer nothing in damages. That is the outcome of ICG Manager Ltd v Colliers International Valuation UK LLP (2026) EWHC 2927 (BP), handed down on 13 November 2026 by Mr David Halpern KC, sitting as a High Court judge [1]. The lender's negligent valuation claim cleared the hurdles of duty and breach. It then fell at causation, because the lender could not prove what it would have done with a correct figure.

Key takeaways

  • The valuation was negligent. Colliers valued a Runcorn shopping centre at £23.75m as at 30 January 2018. The court found the true value was £19m [1].
  • The bracket was 15%. The highest non-negligent figure was therefore £21.85m. The valuation was outside it.
  • The claim was still dismissed. The lender could not prove it would have sold the property sooner and for more. No recoverable loss was caused.
  • Neither expert was "wholly reliable". The judge fixed his own figure between the two, weighted 2:1 towards the lender's expert.
  • A revaluation carries the same duty as a first valuation. A valuer updating a figure for an existing loan owes the same scope of duty as one valuing for a new loan.

The facts behind the negligent valuation claim

The property was Shopping City, Halton Lea, in Runcorn, Cheshire. It was built in the 1970s and had nearly 500,000 square feet on three floors. Both sides agreed it was a secondary shopping centre. The largest tenant, Tesco, had a lease with 52 years unexpired but had moved out in 2015 and sub-let its unit [1].

In 2015 Colliers valued the centre at £28.44m. No complaint was made about that figure. ICG, lending on behalf of two pension schemes, then advanced £17.75m secured on the property. The loan terms required the loan to value ratio to stay at or below 75%.

In January 2018 ICG asked Colliers for an updated valuation. A draft report put the value at £22.41m. After the valuer spoke to the borrower's asset manager, the figure rose to £23.75m. That gave a loan to value ratio of 74.74%, just inside the 75% limit.

What followed was stark:

  • In December 2018, another firm told ICG informally that the centre was likely to be worth between £8.5m and £9m.
  • In January 2019, Colliers revalued it at £15.93m.
  • Receivers were appointed in July 2019.
  • The centre was put on the market in June 2021 and sold for £10.25m, completing in October 2021.

ICG sued. It said that with a competent valuation in January 2018 it would have called in the loan and sold the centre by the end of September 2018, at a much higher price.

What the court decided

Scope of duty: a revaluation is not a lesser job

Colliers argued that this case was different from the usual lender claim. The loan had already been made in 2015, so the lender was already exposed. The judge rejected that. He held that the scope of a valuer's duty on a revaluation for an existing loan is "in principle, exactly the same" as on a valuation for a proposed loan [1]. The differences lie in causation and loss, not in duty.

Breach: the bracket and the bottom line

The judge applied the Court of Appeal's decision in Bratt v Jones, which both sides accepted as the leading authority. Three rules follow from it, as summarised in the judgment [1]:

  1. There can be no finding of negligence unless the valuation falls outside the bracket, meaning the permissible margin of error. That is so "however negligent the methodology".
  2. Being outside the bracket is necessary but not enough. The claimant must also show a lack of reasonable care and skill.
  3. The width of the bracket is a question of fact, decided on expert evidence. The more complex or unusual the property, the wider it is likely to be.

The lender's expert valued the centre at £17.15m. Colliers' expert said £22.75m. The judge found the true value was £19m, and set the bracket at 15%. He said the court should fix one overall bracket and "not apply a separate bracket to each individual calculation".

That made £21.85m the top of the non-negligent range. The £23.75m valuation was above it. The judge then found a lack of reasonable care for four reasons:

  • The report contained a "Special Remark" that a sale at that stage "would only be likely to occur under distressed conditions", yet the valuation took no account of it.
  • It did not take enough account of the centre's unattractive features.
  • It focused solely on the initial yield and overstated the market rent, placing too much weight on historic evidence in a falling market.
  • Many of the yield comparables were either historic or were purchases by local authorities as part of regeneration schemes.

Causation: where the negligent valuation claim failed

ICG had to prove its "counterfactual": what it would have done if properly advised. The burden was on ICG.

The judge accepted that ICG relied on the valuation. He also accepted that a prudent lender likely to recover about 100% of its loan would want to sell quickly in a falling market. But he was not satisfied that ICG would in fact have sold in September 2018.

Two points weighed heavily. First, when ICG learned the bad news in December 2018, it moved "at a very leisurely pace" for the next 16 months. Second, any sale in September 2018 would probably have been a distressed sale with reduced marketing. The judge applied a 20% discount, giving a likely price of about £11.36m. It was "far from obvious" that ICG would have accepted that.

"ICG has failed to establish its Counterfactual case. Accordingly no recoverable loss was caused by Colliers' negligence." [1]

The claim was dismissed. Costs and other consequential matters were left for a later hearing.

The liability cap

The judge added that, had it mattered, he would have rejected Colliers' attempt to limit its liability to £1m. The engagement was formed when the instruction letter was accepted without qualification. It was "too late" to introduce a cap in terms and conditions attached to the valuation report itself [1].

Expert evidence: how the court treated the two valuers

The judge said plainly: "I am unable to accept either expert as wholly reliable."

Criticisms of the lender's expert

  • He relied on details of the key comparable taken from the report under attack, without checking them himself. He missed two important facts about that comparable as a result.
  • He did not mention comparables he had considered and rejected. The judge said some should have been mentioned, "even if only to explain why he did not rely on them".
  • He did not engage with new material from the other expert at their joint meetings, though the judge noted that part of the fault may have lain with the other side.
  • He served a supplementary report the day before trial, changing his method for the larger units without a satisfactory explanation.
  • He changed his bracket in the witness box, from 10-12.5% to 12.5-15%.

Criticisms of the valuer's expert

  • He relied on a market index built largely from data on prime centres as evidence of the market for secondary centres. The judge held he was wrong to do so, and wrong to downplay that reliance when questioned.
  • He gave an opinion on what the lender would have done, which was outside his remit.
  • He did not mention published professional guidance on shopping centre valuation written by the opposing expert.
  • He treated local authority regeneration purchases as ordinary market evidence. The judge agreed with the other side that those buyers were special purchasers.
  • He used comparables that post-dated the valuation date.

The judge found the criticisms of the second expert "more serious". He was left with "the uncomfortable feeling" that the expert "was arguing the case for Colliers and not simply doing his best to assist the court". By contrast, the first expert readily accepted his errors under cross-examination.

Methodology points worth noting

  • Falling markets change the weight of evidence. A hierarchy of comparable evidence works in a static market. It "cannot be rigidly applied in a falling market", where deals more than six months old may need significant adjustment.
  • Headline rents can mislead. Where tenants received rent-free periods, cash incentives and capped service charges, the judge held that market rent should be assessed on a net effective basis, with an allowance for a permanent running void.
  • Hindsight is out. Transactions after the valuation date must be ignored, save for limited weight where a deal was already in negotiation and would have been known to a competent valuer.
  • The judge is not bound by either figure. He declined to send inputs back to the experts for recalculation and fixed the value himself.

Experts owe their duty to the court. Practice Direction 35 says they must give "objective, unbiased opinions" and "should not assume the role of an advocate" [2]. This judgment shows how a court responds when it thinks that line has been crossed. More on the role is set out on the page about acting as a valuation dispute expert witness.

What it means for owners, lenders and investors in west London

The property was a shopping centre in Cheshire, but the principles are general. They apply to any formal valuation relied on for lending, purchase or dispute, including valuations of homes, shops and investment property in Notting Hill, Kensington and the wider area.

Practical points:

  • A valuation that later proves too high is not negligent for that reason alone. It must fall outside the bracket, and the valuer must have failed to take reasonable care.
  • Proving loss is a separate task. Keep records of what decisions were made on the strength of the valuation, and why.
  • Read the report's caveats. Here, a warning buried in the report was at odds with the headline figure.
  • Check the terms of engagement at the start, including any liability cap.
  • When commissioning a valuation, ask how the comparables were chosen, how old they are, and whether they have been adjusted for incentives.

Readers can find background in the guide to what a RICS valuation is and how the Red Book applies, and on the pages covering commercial valuation, freehold valuation and lease extension valuation.

Frequently asked questions

What is the "bracket" in a valuation negligence case?

It is the permissible margin of error around the correct value. Valuation is a matter of opinion, so two careful valuers can differ. A valuation inside the bracket cannot be found negligent. In this case the bracket was 15% for a complex shopping centre [1].

Is a valuation outside the bracket always negligent?

No. The court said it is "a good starting-point" but "not sufficient". The claimant must still show that the valuer did not use reasonable care and skill.

Why did the lender recover nothing if the valuation was negligent?

Because it could not prove causation. It had to show, on the balance of probabilities, that a correct valuation would have led it to sell earlier at a better price. The court was not persuaded.

Can a valuer rely on a liability cap in its standard terms?

Only if the cap is part of the contract. Here the judge said he would have rejected a £1m cap contained in terms attached to the valuation report, after the instruction had already been accepted.

Conclusion: lessons from this negligent valuation claim

ICG v Colliers shows that a negligent valuation claim has three separate stages, and that winning two of them is not enough. Valuers should test comparables hard and adjust for incentives. Lenders and owners should act promptly on bad news and record their decisions. Experts should verify facts independently and stay out of advocacy.

Next steps for anyone concerned about a valuation:

  1. Gather the instruction letter, terms of engagement and the full report.
  2. Obtain an independent retrospective valuation as at the original date.
  3. Take legal advice early, as time limits apply.

This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Anyone considering a claim should take advice from a solicitor and a chartered surveyor on their own facts.

References

  1. ICG Manager Limited and others v Colliers International Valuation UK LLP (2026) EWHC 2927 (BP), The National Archives, 13 November 2026. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
  2. Practice Direction 35: Experts and Assessors, Ministry of Justice. justice.gov.uk.
Content Overview
Table of Contents
Search
Categories ----
Recent Post ----