The Upper Tribunal had jurisdiction to modify the covenant. It accepted that holiday letting was a reasonable use. It still said no. The applicants in Aboaba v Phillip, decided on 5 November 2026, lost for two reasons that should concern any owner thinking about short lets behind a restrictive covenant: they acted first and applied later, and they put no restrictive covenant valuation evidence before the Tribunal at all [1].
Key Takeaways
- A 2003 covenant preventing use of any building as a dwellinghouse remains in force at Shride Barn in Somerset, and the converted annexe cannot continue as a holiday let.
- The Tribunal found the covenant was not obsolete, but that it impeded a reasonable use and that the benefits it secured were real but not substantial, so it had power to modify.
- It declined to exercise that power because the applicants had knowingly breached the covenant before seeking retrospective approval.
- The Tribunal recorded that it had "received no evidence on the value" the restriction secured, and no compensation figure was proposed.
- For Notting Hill owners of mews houses, garden flats and converted outbuildings, the case shows that covenant and short-let questions need a valuer as well as a planning consent.
The facts of Aboaba v Phillip
Johnson Aboaba and Lena Buhler bought Shride Barn, Othery, near Bridgwater, in July 2024. A covenant imposed in a 2003 transfer, for the benefit of the neighbouring Shride Farm House owned by Steven Phillip, barred the use of any building on the land as a dwellinghouse [1].
An outbuilding, the annexe, had been redeveloped in 2008 as a home office, laboratory and workshop. A 2024 certificate of lawful use treated it as ancillary residential accommodation. The applicants wanted to use it as a holiday let. Mr Phillip had refused a request in 2024 to agree an amendment to the covenant, before the applicants completed their purchase [1].
Retrospective planning permission for an annexe and holiday let was granted in April 2026, subject to a management plan limiting guests to four, imposing quiet hours from 9pm to 7am and banning amplified music. The applicants had already been letting the annexe to holidaymakers before the permission was granted, which the Tribunal treated as a knowing breach of the covenant [1].
The application under section 84(1) of the Law of Property Act 1925 was heard by Mrs Diane Martin TD MRICS FAAV, a chartered surveyor and valuer member of the Lands Chamber, after a site inspection on 18 August 2026 and a hearing on 19 and 20 August 2026. Ms Antonia Halker represented the applicants. Mr Phillip represented himself [1].
How the grounds were decided
| Ground | Argument | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| (a) Obsolescence | Changes in the neighbourhood made the covenant obsolete | Failed. The covenant still protects Shride Farm House from residential development; tourism elsewhere did not change the character of the area enough |
| (aa) Impeding reasonable use | Holiday letting is reasonable and the covenant blocks it | Jurisdiction established. The use was reasonable, the covenant impeded it, and the benefits secured were real but not substantial |
| (c) No injury | Modification would not injure the objector | Not separately determined |
| Discretion | Should the Tribunal modify? | No. The applicants knowingly breached the covenant and sought retrospective approval; rewarding that would not be fair |
The application failed, and the covenant remains in force. An appeal lies to the Court of Appeal on a point of law, with permission, within one month [1].
The missing restrictive covenant valuation evidence
The most striking line in the decision is the Tribunal's statement that it had "received no evidence on the value" that the restriction secured. The applicants proposed no compensation figure. Mr Phillip's evidence was lay evidence about noise, traffic, privacy and the effect of paying guests on his home [1].
A Tribunal presided over by a chartered valuer was asked to modify a covenant without a single valuation figure before it.
Ground (aa) asks whether the covenant secures practical benefits of substantial value or advantage, and whether money would be adequate compensation. Both questions invite valuation evidence: what is the benefit worth to the objector, and what would the applicant's land gain from release? Without that evidence the Tribunal could find jurisdiction, as it did, but it could not quantify compensation, and the applicants gave it nothing to weigh against the knowing breach when it came to discretion.
Why this matters in Notting Hill
Notting Hill and the wider Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea contain a high density of mews houses, garden flats, converted coach houses and studios, many of them subject to covenants imposed on sale-offs in the twentieth century. Short-term letting is common, and London's planning rules already limit short lets of whole dwellings to a set number of nights a year without permission.
Aboaba v Phillip adds three warnings for owners in the area.
Planning permission does not release a covenant
The applicants obtained retrospective planning permission with a management plan. The covenant was unaffected. In Notting Hill, a lawful development certificate or a short-let consent does nothing to a covenant benefiting a neighbour.
Breach first, apply later, is a losing strategy
The Tribunal's refusal turned on discretion. Owners who begin letting before resolving the covenant risk the same outcome, even when they can satisfy a ground under section 84.
The covenant has a value, and so does release
Covenants restricting use affect Red Book valuations for sale, remortgage and lease extension. A valuer can quantify the uplift that release would give the burdened land and the diminution, if any, to the benefited land. That evidence is central to a section 84 application and to any negotiated release.
Expert evidence before the Lands Chamber
Section 84 applications are decided on evidence, and the Lands Chamber expects expert valuation evidence to follow the same disciplines as the courts. The Tribunal's own procedure rules and practice directions govern expert reports, and in practice valuers follow the model of CPR Part 35 and Practice Direction 35: a statement of instructions, the material relied on, a reasoned opinion with any range of values, and a statement of truth. The RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, effective from 30 November 2026, applies in full to chartered surveyors appearing before the Tribunal.
A properly instructed valuer in a case like Aboaba v Phillip would normally address:
- the market value of the applicant's property with and without the restriction;
- the value, if any, that the restriction adds to the objector's property;
- the compensation that would be payable under section 84(1)(i) or (ii) if the covenant were modified;
- comparable evidence of holiday-let or short-let premiums in the locality.
None of that was before the Tribunal here.
What this means for Notting Hill homeowners and investors
- Before short-letting a mews house, garden flat or converted outbuilding, check the title for covenants restricting use, not just the planning position.
- If a covenant exists, approach the beneficiary before letting begins. A negotiated release, priced by a valuer, is usually cheaper than a contested application.
- Do not start the use and apply afterwards. The Tribunal has shown that a knowing breach can defeat an otherwise viable application.
What this means for surveyors and solicitors
- Solicitors advising on section 84 applications should instruct a valuer early to address both jurisdiction and compensation.
- Valuers should present covenant release and compensation evidence as independent expert opinion, compliant with the Tribunal's requirements and the RICS standard.
- Surveyors carrying out Level 2 or Level 3 surveys or Red Book valuations in Kensington and Chelsea should flag restrictive covenants affecting use where the title or the client's intentions make them relevant.
Conclusion
Aboaba v Phillip is a reminder that the Lands Chamber decides covenant cases on evidence and conduct, not on planning permission alone. The applicants established jurisdiction yet lost on discretion, with no restrictive covenant valuation evidence to support them. For Notting Hill owners considering short lets, the practical lesson is to read the title, instruct a valuer and resolve the covenant before the first guest arrives. The decision is published on the National Archives Find Case Law service [1].
References
- Johnson Aboaba and Lena Buhler v Steven Phillip (2026) UKUT 424 (LC), Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber), Mrs Diane Martin TD MRICS FAAV, 5 November 2026. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.