Two things changed for West London flat owners within a fortnight of each other. On 1 November 2026 the second edition of the RICS cladding valuation standard took effect, rewriting when a mortgage valuer may ask for an EWS1 form [1]. Then on 12 November 2026 the RICS UK Residential Market Survey reported the weakest sales outlook since 2023 [2]. Put together, they mean that valuers in Notting Hill, Kensington and Holland Park are applying new rules to buildings with cladding at exactly the moment lenders are most cautious about value.
This article explains what the RICS cladding valuation standard EWS1 changes actually are, how they interact with down-valuations, and what to do if a valuation of a flat in a mansion block or modern scheme comes back lower than the agreed price.
Key Takeaways
- The RICS professional standard on valuing flats in multi-storey, multi-occupancy residential buildings with cladding (second edition) applies to RICS members and regulated firms from 1 November 2026 [1].
- Valuers should now request an EWS1 form only where there is a defined reason, using criteria based on building height and construction features [1].
- In some cases a PAS 9980 fire risk appraisal summary can be used instead of an EWS1, provided it states clearly whether remedial works are required [1].
- An EWS1 is for valuation and lending only. It is not a fire safety certificate and does not replace the building's fire risk assessment [1].
- A down-valuation can be challenged with comparable evidence, a reconsideration request to the lender and, where necessary, an independent Red Book valuation or expert report.
What the RICS cladding valuation standard EWS1 changes mean
RICS announced the second edition on 14 May 2026 after consulting fire-safety professionals, valuers, insurers and lenders. It applies to mortgage valuations of residential and mixed-use buildings containing flats [1].
Narrower EWS1 requests
The headline change is restraint. Valuers should request an EWS1 only when there is a defined reason to do so. RICS says the aim is to cut unnecessary requests while still flagging external wall risks that could affect value or marketability [1]. For years, buyers of flats in low-rise Notting Hill conversions were asked for forms their buildings never needed. The new standard is designed to stop that.
Height-based criteria
The standard sets criteria by building height and construction features, including visible cladding, curtain-wall systems and certain balcony designs. It treats buildings over six storeys, buildings of five to six storeys, and buildings of four or fewer storeys differently [1]. A four-storey stucco terrace converted into flats in the 1980s sits in a very different category from a nine-storey scheme off Westbourne Grove.
The PAS 9980 alternative
Where the building has had a fire risk appraisal of its external walls under PAS 9980, a summary or executive summary completed by a suitably qualified professional can, in certain cases, be used instead of an EWS1. It must clearly state whether remedial works are required [1].
Clarified purpose
RICS is explicit that the EWS1 form is for valuation and lending purposes only. It is not a fire safety certificate and does not replace a formal fire risk assessment. Buyers and their solicitors should still review the building's fire risk assessment during the purchase [1].
"Mortgage valuations must give lenders and borrowers clear and proportionate advice." – Nigel Sellars, RICS senior specialist for residential valuation [1]
| Issue | Position from 1 November 2026 |
|---|---|
| When to request an EWS1 | Only where there is a defined reason |
| How buildings are categorised | By height band and construction features |
| Alternative evidence | PAS 9980 appraisal summary in certain cases |
| What an EWS1 proves | Suitability for lending, not fire safety |
Why the market hook matters for valuations
The 12 November 2026 RICS survey reported that sales expectations had fallen to their lowest level since 2023 [2]. That is not a reason to speculate about prices. It is a reason to expect lender valuers to be conservative, to lean on the most recent comparable evidence, and to apply the cladding standard carefully. In a cautious market, any uncertainty about external wall status is more likely to be reflected in a reduced figure or a deferred valuation.
What a down-valuation is and why it happens
A down-valuation occurs when the lender's valuer reports a market value below the agreed purchase price or the figure the borrower expected on a remortgage. The lender then bases its loan on the lower figure.
A mortgage valuation is carried out under RICS Valuation – Global Standards, usually called the Red Book. The valuer must reach an independent opinion of market value from evidence, not from the asking price. Common causes in Notting Hill include:
- Thin or unusual comparable evidence for period conversions.
- Lease length, ground rent and service charge issues.
- Uncertainty about cladding, external wall systems or remediation plans.
- Condition issues such as damp, roof defects or outdated services.
A market appraisal from an estate agent is not a valuation. It is a marketing opinion and carries no professional liability.
How to challenge a down-valuation
- Ask for the valuer's reasoning. Many lenders will share the comparables used.
- Submit better evidence. Three or more recent sales of similar flats in the same street or block, ideally within six months, carry real weight.
- Request a reconsideration. Most lenders have a formal process. Keep it factual.
- Commission an independent RICS valuation. A chartered valuer's Red Book report can support renegotiation with the seller or an application to another lender.
- Resolve the cladding question. If the issue is external wall status, obtain the fire risk assessment, any PAS 9980 appraisal and the managing agent's position on the Building Safety Act leaseholder protections.
- Complain if the process was flawed. Lenders' complaints procedures apply, and the Financial Ombudsman Service may consider complaints about how a lender handled the valuation.
Expert valuation evidence in disputes
Valuation disputes do not stop at mortgage applications. Matrimonial settlements, probate, lease extensions and professional negligence claims all turn on independent valuation evidence.
Where a dispute reaches court or tribunal, the valuer becomes an expert witness. CPR Part 35 imposes an overriding duty to the court, a statement of truth and a clear statement of instructions. From 30 November 2026 the RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, adds requirements to disclose AI use, to disclose heavy reliance on one instructing party, and to set out assumptions and alternative conclusions in full [3].
For a Notting Hill flat with cladding questions, a competent expert valuer will:
- State the external wall assumptions made and show how value changes if they are wrong.
- Use the new height-based categories rather than a blanket EWS1 demand.
- Separate the effect of remediation uncertainty from the effect of market conditions.
- Keep the comparable evidence verifiable.
Practical steps for West London flat owners and buyers
- Before marketing a flat, ask the managing agent for the fire risk assessment, any PAS 9980 appraisal and any EWS1 already on file.
- Check the lease term and service charge accounts, since these drive value as much as the building fabric.
- If buying, instruct a RICS Level 2 or Level 3 survey alongside the lender's valuation so condition issues are identified early.
- If a down-valuation arrives, act quickly: evidence, reconsideration, then an independent valuation.
- If a negligence claim is being considered against a valuer, obtain an independent expert opinion on whether the figure fell outside the acceptable bracket before issuing proceedings.
Frequently asked questions
Does every flat in a building with cladding need an EWS1 from November 2026?
No. The second edition of the RICS standard says valuers should request an EWS1 only where there is a defined reason, judged by building height and construction features [1].
Can a PAS 9980 report replace the EWS1?
In certain cases, yes. A PAS 9980 fire risk appraisal summary or executive summary completed by a suitably qualified professional can be used, provided it states clearly whether remedial works are required [1].
Is an EWS1 proof that the building is safe?
No. RICS states that the EWS1 is for valuation and lending only and does not replace a fire risk assessment [1].
Can a lender valuation be appealed?
Most lenders allow a reconsideration request supported by comparable evidence. If that fails, an independent Red Book valuation can support renegotiation or a fresh application elsewhere.
Conclusion
The RICS cladding valuation standard EWS1 changes from 1 November 2026 should reduce unnecessary form requests and bring more consistency to the valuation of flats in Notting Hill and across West London. They arrive, though, in a cautious lending market where down-valuations are more likely and where cladding uncertainty is quickly priced in.
The practical response is preparation. Gather the building's fire safety documents before a sale or remortgage, understand which height band the building falls into, and be ready to challenge a low figure with evidence rather than frustration. Where a valuation dispute escalates, instruct an independent chartered valuer who works to Red Book standards and, from 30 November 2026, to the new RICS expert witness standard.
References
- Rics Releases Updated Guidance on Home Valuations. propertyindustryeye.com.
- Weakest Outlook for Sales Since 2023 Rics. mortgagestrategy.co.uk.
- Surveyors Acting as Expert Witnesses. rics.org.