{"content":[]}
An objector asked for £302,223 to release a restrictive covenant. It received nothing, and on 21 October 2026 it was ordered to pay the other side's legal costs as well [1][2]. The reason lies in the restrictive covenant compensation valuation put before the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber). Both valuers failed to answer the question the tribunal had set, and the objector's valuation rested on an assumption the tribunal called "fanciful". This November 2026 update explains the two decisions in Domus Living Limited v Edward VII Estates Limited and what they mean for owners, developers and solicitors dealing with covenants in Notting Hill, Kensington and the rest of prime London.
This article is general information only. It is not legal, tax or financial advice.
Key Takeaways
- The tribunal discharged a covenant limiting a plot to one house of a set design, and awarded nil compensation against a claim of £302,223 [1].
- In a second decision, [2026] UKUT 407 (LC), the objector was ordered to pay the applicant's costs because it carried on with an objection that had no factual basis [2].
- The objector's valuer did not carry out the valuation exercise the tribunal had directed, so her evidence gave the tribunal no help.
- The applicant did not escape criticism. Its letter of instruction to its own valuer was faulted, and indemnity costs were refused.
Key facts at a glance
The dispute concerned a new house built larger than a covenant allowed, and whether the party with the benefit of the covenant lost anything of value when the covenant was removed. The facts below are taken from the two published decisions [1][2].
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Case | Domus Living Limited v Edward VII Estates Limited |
| Main decision | [2026] UKUT 287 (LC), 5 August 2026 |
| Costs decision | [2026] UKUT 407 (LC), 21 October 2026 |
| Tribunal | Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) |
| Panel | Upper Tribunal Judge Elizabeth Cooke and Mrs Diane Martin MRICS FAAV |
| Hearing | 25 and 26 June 2026 |
| Statute | Section 84, Law of Property Act 1925 |
| Property | A house on the King Edward VII estate, Midhurst |
| Compensation claimed | £302,223 |
| Compensation awarded | Nil |
| Costs | Objector to pay applicant's costs on the standard basis |
The covenants were imposed in a transfer of the plot dated 8 June 2015, at a price of £695,000. One covenant allowed only a single house built in line with a 2014 planning approval. A second required consent for material external alterations. A later owner obtained a fresh planning permission in October 2017 and built a six-bedroom house about 1,263 sq ft larger than the 2014 design, in breach of both covenants [1].
What the tribunal decided on the covenant
The tribunal discharged both covenants. The consent covenant went by agreement. The building covenant was discharged on three of the statutory grounds in section 84(1): ground (a), that it was obsolete; ground (aa), that it impeded a reasonable use of the land and conferred no practical benefit; and ground (c), that discharge would cause no injury [1][3].
The objector argued that the larger house might lead the planning authority to look again at the wider estate and allow less development on its retained land. The tribunal found no evidence for that risk. The objector also alleged a cynical breach. That was rejected. The tribunal accepted that the person behind the applicant company had been careless but had not known of the covenant until 2024 [1].
How the restrictive covenant compensation valuation went wrong
The valuation evidence failed because it did not answer the tribunal's question. This is the part of the case that matters most to surveyors and to anyone instructing them.
The question the experts were set
The tribunal directed the two valuation experts to value the objector's retained land on two bases: one with no risk of the planning authority reassessing the estate, and one with that risk. The difference would show what the covenant was really worth to the objector [1].
The objector's valuer
The objector's expert did not value the retained land as a whole. She looked only at one yard of 1,133 sq m, on the footing that it would obtain planning permission for housing, and put the loss at about £230,000 [1].
The tribunal's criticism was direct. It compared the approach to being asked to value land at risk of flooding and instead valuing it as if the flood had already happened. A risk had been treated as a certainty. The key assumption was described as "fanciful", and the evidence was held to be of no help to the tribunal [1].
The applicant's valuer
The applicant's expert concluded there was no material difference in value between the two scenarios. He did not attend the hearing and was not cross-examined, and the tribunal did not need to rely on his report [1]. The costs decision later recorded that both experts had failed to follow the tribunal's valuation instruction, and that the applicant's letter of instruction to its expert deserved criticism [2].
The second head of compensation
Section 84 allows compensation under two heads: a sum for loss or disadvantage caused by the discharge, or a sum to make up for any reduction in the price received for the land when the covenant was imposed [3]. On the first head there was no injury, so no loss. On the second, the objector's valuer said the plot would have been worth £985,000 in 2015 without the covenant, against the £695,000 paid. The tribunal had little confidence in her use of comparable evidence, thought her assumptions optimistic, and regarded £985,000 as unrealistic. Nothing was awarded [1].
A valuation of a risk must value the risk, not the worst outcome treated as certain.
Why the objector had to pay the costs
Costs were awarded because the objector acted unreasonably in pressing on, not merely because it lost. The starting point in section 84 cases is that an unsuccessful objector does not normally pay the applicant's costs, since defending a property right is legitimate [2].
The tribunal gave these reasons for departing from that starting point [2]:
- The land the objector said it wanted to protect belonged to another company, which was found not to have the benefit of the covenant. The objector did not reassess its case after that.
- Its director had not checked the basic facts. No enquiry had been made of the planning authority about the supposed risk.
- The objection was found to be "completely without substance".
- The objector's officers could have seen that the expert evidence would not help.
The tribunal said a reasonable objector would have withdrawn. Costs were ordered on the standard basis. The higher indemnity basis was refused because of the applicant's own shortcomings, including the letter of instruction [2].
Lessons for Notting Hill and Kensington owners and their solicitors
The lesson for prime London is that a covenant claim needs evidence of real loss, valued on realistic assumptions. Many properties in Notting Hill, Holland Park and Kensington are subject to old estate covenants that limit building, alterations or use, and extensions or redevelopment can bring those covenants into play.
For owners with the benefit of a covenant:
- Identify the practical benefit the covenant secures, such as light, outlook, privacy or development control, before putting a price on it.
- Check who actually owns the land that benefits. Company restructures can move it.
- Review the case when the facts change. Pressing on regardless can lead to a costs order.
For owners, developers and their solicitors seeking a release:
- Read the title before building. Carelessness was forgiven here, but a knowing breach carries more risk.
- Expect a proposed release fee to be tested against what the objector could prove at the tribunal.
- Draft the expert's letter of instruction to match the tribunal's directions, and make sure the expert can attend for cross-examination.
What the case means for expert witnesses
An expert's duty is to the tribunal, and the first task is to answer the question asked. The case suggests a short checklist for surveyors giving evidence on a restrictive covenant compensation valuation:
- Follow the directed valuation bases. If one seems unworkable, say so and explain why.
- Value the whole of the land said to benefit, not a selected part.
- Separate a risk from a certainty.
- Support planning assumptions with enquiries or documents.
- Stand back and test the result against the actual transaction history.
FAQ
What compensation can be awarded when a restrictive covenant is discharged?
Section 84 of the Law of Property Act 1925 allows the Upper Tribunal to award a sum under one of two heads: loss or disadvantage suffered because of the discharge or modification, or the effect the covenant had in reducing the price received for the land when it was imposed [3]. If neither is proved, the award can be nil.
Does an objector usually pay costs if the covenant is discharged?
No. The tribunal confirmed that an unsuccessful objector does not normally pay the applicant's costs unless it has acted unreasonably. In Domus Living the objector was ordered to pay because it continued with an objection that had no factual foundation [2].
Can a covenant be discharged after it has already been breached?
It can. Here the house had already been built in breach, and the tribunal still discharged the covenant after rejecting the claim that the breach was cynical. The outcome depends on the facts of each case [1].
Conclusion
Domus Living v Edward VII Estates shows that a restrictive covenant compensation valuation stands or falls on its assumptions. A claim for £302,223 produced a nil award and a costs order because the loss could not be shown and the expert evidence did not address the question set.
Next steps for owners and advisers in prime London:
- obtain independent valuation advice before making or resisting a compensation claim;
- agree clear, neutral instructions for the expert at the outset;
- keep the strength of the case under review as the evidence develops;
- take legal advice on the title and on the section 84 grounds.
References
- Domus Living Limited v Edward VII Estates Limited, UKUT 287 (LC), Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber), 5 August 2026 (The National Archives). caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
- Domus Living Limited v Edward VII Estates Limited (costs), UKUT 407 (LC), Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber), 21 October 2026 (The National Archives). caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
- Law of Property Act 1925, section 84 (legislation.gov.uk). legislation.gov.uk.