Almacantar Centre Point v de Valk (2026) EWCA Civ 1466: Court of Appeal Confirms Leaseholder Protection for an ‘Unsafe’ Facade Is Not Limited to Fire Risk, What It Means for Notting Hill Flat Owners, Surveyors and Expert Evidence (November 2026)

A facade that has been defective since the day it was finished, a repair bill expected to pass £12 million, and thirteen leaseholders who say the law stops the landlord charging them for it. On 17 November 2026 the Court of Appeal agreed with the leaseholders in Almacantar Centre Point Nominee No.1 Limited v de Valk (2026) EWCA Civ 1466 [1]. The ruling matters well beyond one London landmark. It shapes how any building defects claim over cladding and leaseholders' service charges will be argued, and it shows how much turns on the expert evidence given at the first hearing.

Key Takeaways

  • The landlord's appeal failed on all five grounds. Lord Justice Newey and Lord Justice Fancourt gave a joint judgment, and Lord Justice Miles agreed.
  • The service charge bar is wide. Paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 to the Building Safety Act 2022 is not confined to "relevant defects" as defined elsewhere in the Act.
  • "Unsafe" does not just mean a fire risk. The court rejected the argument that the protection covers only fire safety problems.
  • Whether a facade is "cladding" is a question of fact. The First-tier Tribunal heard the experts and made its findings. The Court of Appeal found no error of law.
  • One point is left open. The court did not decide whether a cladding system can make up the whole of an external wall.

The building and the defect

Centre Point House is part of the 1960s Centre Point development by Charing Cross Road and New Oxford Street. It has shops and restaurants on two levels, with 36 duplex flats in a six-storey block above. The building is listed.

The First-tier Tribunal (FTT) found that the facade "is not in good and substantial repair and condition" and had been "inherently defective" from completion. The freeholders plan to fix it by adding a new steel curtain wall system over the existing timber frame. Counsel told the court the total cost is expected to exceed £12 million including VAT and fees.

In January 2023 the freeholders asked the FTT to decide whether the cost could be recovered through the service charge. The FTT held that the works fell within the landlord's repairing covenants. It then held that tenants with "qualifying leases" did not have to pay, because of the Building Safety Act. The Upper Tribunal upheld that result, and the freeholders appealed again.

What the Building Safety Act says

Schedule 8 to the Building Safety Act 2022 contains several protections for leaseholders. Paragraph 8 is one of the strongest. It says that no service charge is payable under a qualifying lease for "cladding remediation". That means removing or replacing any part of a cladding system that forms the outer wall of an external wall system and is unsafe.

A qualifying lease is, broadly, a long lease of a single home in a building of at least 11 metres or five storeys, granted before 14 February 2022, where on that date the flat was the tenant's main home or the tenant owned no more than three UK homes.

The five arguments and how they were decided

Ground Landlord's argument Outcome
1 Paragraph 8 only applies to a "relevant defect" Rejected. The paragraph "is not stated to apply only in relation to 'relevant defects'"
2 The facade was not "cladding" A question of fact for the FTT. No error of law
3 The works were not removal or replacement of part of a cladding system Dismissed on the FTT's findings
4 The system did not form the "outer wall" of an external wall system Dismissed. Wider question reserved
5 "Unsafe" means unsafe because of fire Rejected. The word is not limited to fire risk

The practical effect is that qualifying leaseholders at Centre Point House do not have to contribute to the facade scheme through the service charge. The judgment does not set out a costs order or any final sums.

The expert evidence that decided the facts

Two facade experts, Dr Harris and Mr Gray, gave evidence at the FTT. They agreed on the key points:

  • the facade was dangerous and the works were urgently needed; and
  • the proposed scheme was "the best, and realistically only, solution".

Dr Harris described the original system as an "early precursor of curtain walling". That kind of technical description fed straight into the FTT's finding that the facade was a cladding system.

The FTT panel itself included two chartered surveyors sitting with a judge. This is a feature of the Property Chamber that parties sometimes overlook. The fact-finders are themselves building professionals, and they are well placed to weigh technical evidence.

Once the tribunal has decided what a facade is and whether it is unsafe, an appeal court will rarely look behind those findings.

Three of the five grounds of appeal ran into that wall. The Court of Appeal treated the nature of the facade as a factual question that the FTT was entitled to answer on the evidence it heard.

Lessons for surveyors and expert witnesses

Describe the construction with care. Whether an element is "cladding", part of an "external wall system" or the wall itself may decide who pays. Reports should explain how the facade is built, what is structural and what is applied, and why.

Address safety in the round. After this ruling, "unsafe" can cover risks other than fire, such as parts of a facade failing or falling. Experts should set out each risk and the evidence for it.

Expect the first hearing to be the one that counts. An expert's agreed statement and oral evidence at the FTT will usually settle the facts for every later appeal.

Keep to the expert's role. The new RICS standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses (5th edition) applies from 30 November 2026 [2]. It restates the duty of independence that tribunals rely on.

What it means for Notting Hill and west London flats

Notting Hill, Bayswater and Kensington have many mid-century and later blocks of five storeys or more, some with curtain walling, panels or timber-framed glazing. For owners, buyers and managers of flats in such buildings, three points follow.

  • Check lease status early. Whether a lease is a qualifying lease can be worth tens of thousands of pounds on a major facade scheme. Buyers should ask for the leaseholder deed of certificate and take advice.
  • Read survey findings on the envelope closely. A RICS Level 2 or Level 3 survey of a flat reports on the parts the surveyor can see. Where the report flags the external wall, ask what further investigation is needed and who would pay for repairs.
  • Expect valuation questions. Where a landlord cannot recover costs from qualifying leaseholders, the bill falls elsewhere. That can affect the value of non-qualifying flats and of the freehold. Disputes of that kind need independent valuation evidence.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does this ruling apply only to combustible cladding?
No. The Court of Appeal held that "unsafe" in paragraph 8 is not limited to fire risk.

Do all leaseholders at Centre Point House escape the cost?
No. The protection applies to qualifying leases. The FTT held that leaseholders without qualifying leases remain liable under their leases.

Could the case go further?
The judgment does not say. An appeal to the Supreme Court would need permission.

Does a defective facade always count as cladding?
No. It depends on the facts of each building, which is why the expert evidence matters so much.

Conclusion

Almacantar v de Valk confirms that the Building Safety Act protection for cladding remediation is broad, and that the meaning of "unsafe" is not tied to fire. It also shows that these cases are won and lost on how the building is described by the experts at the first hearing.

Flat owners in taller blocks should confirm whether their lease qualifies. Landlords and managers planning facade works should take technical and legal advice before issuing demands. Anyone heading for the tribunal should instruct an independent facade or building surveying expert at the outset.

This article is general information on a recent judgment and is not legal advice.

References

  1. Almacantar Centre Point Nominee No.1 Limited & Anor v de Valk & Ors (2026) EWCA Civ 1466. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
  2. RICS, Surveyors acting as expert witnesses. rics.org.
Content Overview
Table of Contents
Search
Categories ----
Recent Post ----