Tomorrow, five Supreme Court justices are due to hear an argument about a bill that 32 flat owners were never meant to see coming: the landlord's own professional costs in a fire safety dispute. The Adriatic Land v Hippersley Point Supreme Court appeal on service charge professional costs asks whether the Building Safety Act 2022 blocks recovery of those costs even where they were run up before the Act took effect [1][2]. For leaseholders and freeholders in Notting Hill and west London, the answer matters well beyond one block.
Key Takeaways
- Hearing date: 18 November 2026, though listings can change [1].
- The question: can legal or professional costs incurred before 28 June 2022 be recovered through the service charge from leaseholders with qualifying leases? [1]
- So far: the Upper Tribunal and a majority of the Court of Appeal said no [1][2].
- Not decided yet: judgment will follow later. The outcome is not known.
- Practical point: records of what was spent, when, and whether it was paid are central.
The Background to Adriatic Land v Hippersley Point
Hippersley Point is a 10-storey mixed-use block, more than 18 metres high, built around 2015. It has 32 long-leasehold flats and one commercial unit. Adriatic Land 5 Limited is the freeholder [1][2].
In 2020, fire safety concerns were identified. Adriatic planned a fire alarm upgrade and facade remediation. Both were "qualifying works" under section 20 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, which normally requires the landlord to consult leaseholders first [1].
Adriatic applied to the First-tier Tribunal for dispensation from that consultation, so the works would not be delayed [2].
| Stage | What happened |
|---|---|
| First-tier Tribunal | Granted dispensation. On review, it added a condition barring Adriatic from recovering the costs of the application from leaseholders [1] |
| Upper Tribunal | Held that condition wrong in law, but decided the costs were irrecoverable anyway under paragraph 9 of Schedule 8 to the Building Safety Act 2022 [1] |
| Court of Appeal | Dismissed Adriatic's appeal by a majority [1][2] |
| Supreme Court | Hearing listed for 18 November 2026 [1] |
In the Court of Appeal, Nugee LJ and Holgate LJ held that from 28 June 2022 the relevant service charges are not payable by qualifying leaseholders, even where the costs had already been incurred or demanded, provided they had not been paid. Newey LJ dissented [2].
The Issue Before the Supreme Court
The court's own summary puts the issue this way: does paragraph 9 of Schedule 8 prevent landlords from recovering legal or professional costs through service charges from leaseholders with qualifying leases, where those costs were incurred before the Act came into effect? [1]
Permission to appeal was granted on the retrospectivity ground on 6 November 2025 [1]. The panel listed is Lord Hamblen, Lord Burrows, Lord Leggatt, Lord Stephens and Lord Doherty. The Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government is an intervener [1].
A linked appeal about remediation contribution orders, involving Triathlon Homes, is listed for the following day [1][2].
The appeals affect how losses are allocated, not whether they exist.
That comment comes from one law firm's preview. It adds that if landlords cannot recover historic costs through service charges, they are likely to pursue developers, contractors or consultants instead [2].
Why Service Charge Professional Costs Matter in Notting Hill
Building safety disputes are expensive before any repair starts. Solicitors, building surveyors and fire engineers are all needed to investigate, specify works and deal with tribunal applications. Someone has to pay those fees.
Notting Hill and its neighbours have many mansion blocks and converted houses held on long leases. In broad terms, the Building Safety Act protects leaseholders with "qualifying leases" from certain building safety costs. Whether a particular lease qualifies depends on the facts, so each leaseholder should check their own position.
Leaseholders should:
- keep every service charge demand, with its date
- note which items are legal or professional fees
- record what has been paid and what has not
- ask the landlord or managing agent how the appeal affects current demands
Freeholders and managing agents should:
- separate professional costs clearly in the accounts
- record when each cost was incurred
- take advice before demanding disputed historic costs
The Surveyor's Role in Service Charge and Section 20 Matters
Chartered building surveyors support both sides of these disputes. They prepare specifications for major works, advise during section 20 consultation, report on defects, and review whether proposed works are needed.
A clear specification and a well-reasoned defect report reduce the room for argument later.
Expert Evidence in Service Charge Disputes
Disputes in the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) often turn on surveyor expert evidence. The expert is usually asked whether the works were necessary, whether they were reasonably specified, and whether the cost was reasonable.
The expert's duty is to the tribunal, not to the party who pays the fee. The RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, takes effect on 30 November 2026 and states that duty in plain terms [3].
Frequently Asked Questions
When will the Supreme Court decide?
No date has been given. Judgment follows some time after the hearing.
Does the case concern the cost of the repair works themselves?
No. It concerns the landlord's legal or professional costs, here the costs of a dispensation application [1].
Does the ruling apply only to Hippersley Point?
No. It will guide how the leaseholder protections apply to historic professional costs generally.
Should a leaseholder stop paying service charges?
Not without advice. The right course depends on the lease and the charge in question.
Conclusion
Adriatic Land v Hippersley Point will decide how far back the Building Safety Act's protection against professional costs reaches. Until the Supreme Court rules, the Court of Appeal's decision stands.
Leaseholders and freeholders should gather their records now, check how charges are described and dated, and take advice on any disputed demand.
This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Take advice on your own circumstances.
References
- UK Supreme Court, case details for UKSC 2025/0157, Adriatic Land 5 Limited v Long Leaseholders at Hippersley Point and another. supremecourt.uk.
- Clyde & Co, "Adriatic and Triathlon in the Supreme Court: BSA retrospectivity to be clarified" (19 October 2026). clydeco.com.
- RICS, Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition (July 2026, effective 30 November 2026). rics.org.