Two chartered valuers looked at the same Grade II listed house in Chester Street, Belgravia, and arrived at figures more than £5 million apart. On 10 November 2026 the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) rejected both approaches and fixed the value at £11 million [1]. For anyone facing an ATED valuation dispute in prime central London, or a capital gains, inheritance tax or stamp duty valuation anywhere in Notting Hill and west London, Internovel Ltd v HMRC is a clear lesson in how tribunals test expert valuation evidence, and why a single valuation band can be worth a great deal of tax.
Key Takeaways
- The Upper Tribunal determined the 1 April 2022 value of 23 Chester Street, Belgravia, at £11 million for ATED purposes, placing it in the £10m to £20m band [1].
- The taxpayer's expert argued £6.54 million using a residual (developer's) valuation; HMRC had assessed £12 million; the Tribunal accepted neither figure [1].
- The Member found that any buyer would have seen the house as needing works throughout, but did not accept that only a developer would have bought it [1].
- Comparable sales must be adjusted for condition and specification, and the Tribunal was surprised that HMRC's expert made no downward adjustment for a superior, refurbished neighbour [1].
- An appeal lies only to the Court of Appeal on a point of law, with permission [1].
What ATED is and why the valuation date of 1 April 2022 matters
The Annual Tax on Enveloped Dwellings (ATED) is charged under the Finance Act 2013 on dwellings held within a corporate "envelope", most commonly a company. The annual charge depends on the valuation band the property falls into, in the same way council tax uses bands. In Internovel the two relevant bands were "more than £5 million but not more than £10 million" and "more than £10 million but not more than £20 million" [1][2].
Valuation dates fall every five years from 1 April 2012, so the date in issue was 1 April 2022. Market value carries the meaning in section 272 of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992: the price the property might reasonably be expected to fetch on a sale in the open market [1]. That same definition underpins capital gains tax valuations, which is why this decision is relevant far beyond ATED, including to any capital gains tax valuation of a west London home.
The appeal consolidated three appeals for the 2024, 2025 and 2026 chargeable years, transferred from the First-tier Tax Tribunal. HMRC had determined the value at £12 million; the appellant company said £6.54 million. The Member, Mrs Diane Martin TD MRICS FAAV, said the appeal raised no issues of law and was purely a determination of value. She heard the case on 23 and 24 September 2026 and inspected the property internally on the first day, accompanied by counsel, solicitors and both experts [1].
The house: 23 Chester Street and why its 2010 to 2012 refurbishment counted against it
Chester Street is a prime Belgravia address of late Georgian and early Victorian terraced houses, most still in single family use. No. 23 is a Grade II listed, part stucco-fronted, mid-terrace house on the south side, laid out over six floors from sub-basement to third floor, with a total gross internal area of 6,114 sq ft [1].
A sub-basement holds a large plant room, cold store and laundry; the basement kitchen opens to a 750 sq ft patio garden; reception rooms, a conservatory and roof terrace sit on the first floor; and only three family bedrooms occupy the second and third floors. A passenger lift serves only up to first-floor level [1].
The house had been gutted, refurbished and extended in 2010 to 2012 under a French interior designer. Both experts agreed the layout was not to the general taste of UK purchasers at this level and that the house would have looked somewhat dated at the valuation date [1]. In an ATED valuation dispute in prime central London, condition and layout drive the price per square foot.
The experts' positions: £9.1m, then £6.54m, against HMRC's £12m
The appellant instructed Mr Eric Shapiro FRICS FCIArb, formerly senior director of professional valuations at Chestertons. HMRC instructed Ms Sogol Shirazi MRICS of the Valuation Office, now part of HMRC, a sector leader for national taxation with extensive prime central London experience [1].
Mr Shapiro's position had moved. In April 2022 he prepared a self-assessment report valuing the house at £9.1 million, relying on 2021 sales at 3, 22 and 32 Chester Street. The Valuation Office valuer responded with £11.5 million and negotiations failed. In his expert report of 25 March 2026 Mr Shapiro changed methodology. He concluded that the best price would come from a developer buying for extensive refurbishment, and ran a residual valuation: gross development value derived from five Chester Street sales, less refurbishment costs and developer's profit, producing £6.54 million with a range of 10 per cent either side. At the hearing he accepted that, with developer's profit stripped out, the top of his range of about £8.69 million was within 5 per cent of his original £9.1 million [1].
The experts did agree on the evidence base: four sales in Chester Street between June 2020 and December 2021 were the key comparables, adjusted to the valuation date using the Savills Prime Central London house price index [1].
How the Tribunal valued the house: comparables, condition and a discount for works
The Member did not accept that only a developer would have bought No. 23. She did, however, find that any purchaser would have viewed it as needing works throughout: reconfiguring the basement, creating more bedroom suites, widening the stairs and bringing the decoration up to a contemporary standard [1].
She then worked from the most useful comparable. The sale of 22 Chester Street had achieved £2,241 per sq ft. Ms Shirazi had adjusted that upwards to £2,353 per sq ft to reflect the subject's sub-basement, but the Member was surprised that no downward adjustment had been made for the fact that No. 22 was sold refurbished, in contemporary style, with five bedrooms and a lift serving five floors, "a much superior house". It was also unclear how Ms Shirazi had derived her own figure of £1,970 per sq ft [1].
On costs of works, Mr Shapiro's £300 per sq ft had been agreed by Ms Shirazi only for the sub-basement. The Member took a worst case of £300 per sq ft across the whole floor area, added professional fees and VAT, and arrived at just over £2.5 million, or about £410 per sq ft. She rejected adding developer's finance, profit and sale costs, because a private buyer would not run a full residual appraisal [1].
Discounting £2,240 per sq ft by £410 gave £1,830 per sq ft, which, she noted, was coincidentally the rate achieved for 3 Chester Street. Applied to 6,114 sq ft, that produced £11,188,620. The determination: £11 million at 1 April 2022, "well above £10 million", and so within the £10m to £20m band [1].
Why the Tribunal rejected both experts' approaches
Neither expert carried the day. The appellant's residual method assumed a single type of purchaser, a developer, and loaded the appraisal with finance, profit and sale costs that an owner-occupier would never deduct [1]. HMRC's comparable approach adjusted upwards for the subject's extra sub-basement but not downwards for the far superior condition of the comparable. In any ATED valuation dispute in prime central London, adjustments must run both ways [1].
Expert valuation evidence: lessons from the decision
- Explain any change of method. A move from £9.1 million to £6.54 million for the same date invites scrutiny. The Member asked for the earlier report precisely to understand what had changed [1].
- Be careful with residual valuations for houses. The residual method is sensitive to cost and profit assumptions, and it presumes a developer purchaser. For a house that is habitable, tribunals may prefer a comparables approach with a discount for works.
- Adjust comparables honestly. Condition, specification, bedroom count and lift provision all matter, and the adjustments must be transparent.
- Show your derivation. A headline rate per square foot that cannot be traced back to the comparables carries little weight.
- Expect the tribunal to inspect and form its own view. The Member used her own judgement after an internal inspection and arrived at a figure neither side had put forward [1].
These points apply equally when a valuer gives evidence in a matrimonial, probate or lease extension dispute, which is why an experienced valuation dispute expert witness will build the report around transparent comparable analysis from the start.
What this means for Notting Hill and prime London owners facing ATED, CGT, IHT or SDLT valuations
Many houses in Notting Hill, Holland Park and Kensington sit close to a tax threshold, and Internovel shows how much turns on the figure: a few hundred pounds per square foot moved this property across the £10 million ATED band line for every chargeable year in the five-year cycle.
Owners who hold property through a company should check whether their self-assessment band is supported by a proper ATED valuation with comparable evidence. The same open market value test applies to capital gains and inheritance tax computations. A dated or unusual specification can legitimately support a lower figure, but only if the discount is evidenced rather than asserted. Where HMRC disagrees, the route runs through the Valuation Office and, if necessary, the tribunals, and understanding what a RICS valuation is and how the Red Book works is the starting point [3].
How Notting Hill Surveyors can help with Red Book tax valuations and valuation disputes
Notting Hill Surveyors provides RICS Red Book valuations for ATED, capital gains tax, inheritance tax and stamp duty purposes across Notting Hill, Holland Park, Kensington, Bayswater and west London, together with probate, matrimonial and lease extension valuations, and prepares expert valuation evidence built on transparent comparable analysis and clearly reasoned adjustments.
This article is general information about a published tribunal decision and is not tax or legal advice.
FAQ
What did the Upper Tribunal decide in Internovel Ltd v HMRC?
It determined that 23 Chester Street, Belgravia, was worth £11 million at 1 April 2022 for ATED purposes, placing it in the £10m to £20m band. The taxpayer had argued £6.54 million and HMRC had assessed £12 million [1].
Why did the taxpayer's expert value the house so much lower?
He used a residual valuation on the basis that only a developer would buy the house for extensive refurbishment, deducting refurbishment costs, finance, developer's profit and sale costs. The Tribunal found a private buyer would discount for the cost of works but not for those other items [1].
How did the Tribunal arrive at £11 million?
It started from the sale of 22 Chester Street at about £2,240 per sq ft, deducted about £410 per sq ft for works, fees and VAT to reach £1,830 per sq ft, and applied that to 6,114 sq ft, giving about £11.19 million, rounded to a determination of £11 million [1].
Can the decision be appealed?
Only to the Court of Appeal, on a point of law, and only with permission [1].
Conclusion
Internovel Ltd v HMRC is a reminder that a tax valuation is only as strong as its comparable evidence and the honesty of its adjustments. The Tribunal rejected a residual appraisal that assumed too much and a comparables approach that adjusted only one way, then found its own figure after inspecting the house. Owners of high-value homes in Notting Hill and across prime London should check that any ATED, CGT, IHT or SDLT valuation they rely on is Red Book compliant, rests on transparent comparables and documents every adjustment for condition, because that is the evidence that survives when HMRC disagrees.
References
- Internovel Limited v HM Revenue & Customs (2026) UKUT 431 (LC), Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber), decision of 10 November 2026, Find Case Law, The National Archives. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
- HMRC, Annual Tax on Enveloped Dwellings: the basics. gov.uk.
- RICS, RICS Valuation – Global Standards (Red Book). rics.org.