A tenant sent the tribunal a schedule of more than 30 rental listings. The tribunal's decision said she had provided no documentation on rental evidence at all. On 23 October 2026 the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) held that this was not accurate, set aside the finding of market rent, and sent that question back to be decided again.
Monaco v Orlando (2026) UKUT 411 (LC), a decision of Upper Tribunal Judge Elizabeth Cooke made on written representations, involved a modest house and two parties without lawyers. Its lesson applies to every rental valuation dispute, including those over high-value lettings in Notting Hill and Holland Park: a valuation finding is only as sound as the treatment of the comparable evidence behind it.
What happened
The property is a three-bedroom semi-detached house in Barnet, north London, let on a 12-month tenancy from 7 June 2024. On 27 August 2025 the landlord served a notice proposing to increase the rent from £1,825 to £2,350 a month with effect from 7 October 2025. The tenant referred the notice to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber).
The tribunal inspected on 13 March 2026 and gave its decision on 16 March 2026. Its valuation ran as follows:
- market rent in good condition: £2,800 a month;
- less £840 a month for condition and the lack of white goods;
- rent determined: £1,960 a month from 7 October 2025.
The landlord had relied on two comparables, at £2,500 and £1,900 a month, and asserted a professional valuation in the range of £2,600 to £2,800. The tribunal called his comparables of limited usefulness. It said it relied on its own expert, general knowledge of rental values. It also said that the tenant had not provided any documentation or submissions on rental evidence.
That last statement was the problem. The tenant had sent a schedule of over 30 listings on 9 January 2026.
What the Upper Tribunal decided
The tenant raised several grounds. Most failed.
- Validity of the notice. There was an error in the form, but it did not mislead the tenant. The question is how a reasonable recipient would have understood the notice. The notice was valid.
- Hardship. The evidence had not been before the First-tier Tribunal, so it could not found an appeal.
- Gas and electrical safety. The tribunal's failure to deal with this evidence was a significant omission, but a further deduction from the rent was most unlikely, so nothing turned on it.
The comparables ground succeeded. Judge Cooke found that the tenant did provide useful material and that it was not taken into consideration.
The landlord argued that the omission made no difference. He said her schedule mostly showed four-bedroom houses, asking rents above £2,350 or properties outside the area, and that none were completed lettings with reliable adjustments. The Upper Tribunal acknowledged the weaknesses. The listings were asking prices, most appeared to be for properties in very good condition, many would eventually have let for less, and the list was not easy to navigate. None of that disposed of the point. The evidence had to be considered.
The £2,800 starting figure was set aside and that element alone was remitted to the First-tier Tribunal. The £840 of deductions stands. The Upper Tribunal suggested directions limiting the tenant to a few comparables next time.
How a market rent is fixed
For an assured periodic tenancy, a landlord proposes a new rent by notice under section 13 of the Housing Act 1988. If the tenant refers it to the tribunal, section 14 requires the tribunal to determine the rent at which the property might reasonably be expected to be let in the open market by a willing landlord, on the terms of the existing tenancy.
That is a valuation exercise. Tribunals are expert bodies and are entitled to use their own knowledge and experience. This decision shows the limit of that entitlement. Where a party has put evidence forward, the tribunal's reasons must show that it was considered and explain, at least briefly, why it was or was not persuasive.
What makes a good comparable
The Upper Tribunal's remarks are a compact guide to weighing rental evidence.
- Completed lettings beat asking rents. An advertised rent shows what a landlord hopes for. A completed letting shows what a tenant agreed to pay.
- Like for like. The same number of bedrooms and the same property type carry most weight. A four-bedroom house says little about a three-bedroom one without adjustment.
- Location. Comparables should come from the same area, or the difference should be explained.
- Condition and specification. A newly refurbished property with appliances is not directly comparable with a tired one without white goods.
- Date. Evidence should be close to the valuation date.
- Adjustments. Each difference should be identified and reflected in a reasoned adjustment.
- Quality over quantity. A short schedule of well-analysed comparables is more use than 30 listings that are hard to navigate.
Expert valuation evidence
No expert valuer gave evidence in this case. The landlord referred to a professional valuation, but the decision does not identify the valuer or describe the report.
In higher-value or more complex rental disputes, a report from an RICS registered valuer can make the difference. A good report will:
- identify the property, the tenancy terms and the valuation date;
- set out each comparable with its address, size, condition, letting date and rent achieved;
- explain the adjustments made and the reasoning that leads to the opinion of rent;
- deal openly with evidence that points the other way.
A valuer who gives expert evidence to a tribunal owes an overriding duty to the tribunal, not to the party who pays the fee. The opinion must be independent. A bare assertion of a valuation range, without the supporting analysis, carries little weight.
Practical lessons for landlords
- Before serving a notice, assemble evidence of completed lettings of similar properties nearby.
- Be realistic about condition. The deductions in this case took £840 a month off the headline figure.
- If the rent is substantial or the property unusual, obtain a reasoned valuation and be ready to disclose it.
Practical lessons for tenants
- Send your evidence in good time and keep proof of when it was sent.
- Select your best few comparables and present them in a clear table: address, bedrooms, condition, rent, date, and whether let or merely advertised.
- If the tribunal's decision does not mention your evidence, that may be a ground of appeal.
Notting Hill Surveyors' RICS registered valuers provide rental and capital valuations and independent expert reports for landlords and tenants across west London.
Frequently asked questions
What did the Upper Tribunal decide in Monaco v Orlando?
It set aside the First-tier Tribunal's finding that the market rent in good condition was £2,800 a month, because the tenant's schedule of comparables had not been considered, and remitted that element for redetermination. The £840 deductions stand.
Did the tenant win a lower rent?
Not yet. The starting figure must be decided again by the First-tier Tribunal. The outcome could be higher, lower or the same.
Can a tribunal rely on its own knowledge of rents?
Yes, tribunals are expert bodies. They must still consider the evidence the parties provide and give reasons that deal with it.
Are asking rents good evidence?
They are weaker than completed lettings. The Upper Tribunal observed that many advertised properties eventually let for less than the asking figure.
When is a professional rental valuation worth obtaining?
Where the rent is high, the property is unusual, the comparables are thin or the other side is professionally advised. The report should be reasoned and independent.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Take specific advice on your own circumstances.