Brickfield Properties v Haines (2026) UKUT 421 (LC): Upper Tribunal Overturns a ‘Blended’ Relativity on a St John’s Wood Lease Extension, Valuation Lessons for Notting Hill Leaseholders (November 2026)

Two valuers disagreed about the value of a short lease by £810. The tribunal hearing the case then picked a figure more than £32,000 higher than either of them. On 28 October 2026 the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) set that decision aside in Brickfield Properties Ltd v Haines (2026) UKUT 421 (LC), and the premium payable by the leaseholders rose from £87,815 to £104,570 [1]. The case is a short and useful guide to how relativity works in a lease extension valuation, and to the limits on what a tribunal may do with the expert evidence in front of it.

Key Takeaways

  • The flat is at Oslo Court, Prince Albert Road, London NW8, with 49.42 years left on the lease.
  • Both valuers put the short lease value at about £400,000. The First-tier Tribunal adopted £433,510 using its own "blended" method.
  • The Upper Tribunal held this was procedurally unfair, because the parties were never given a chance to comment on the method.
  • Averaging a single market sale with the relativity graphs was also wrong as a matter of valuation.
  • Market evidence comes first where it exists. The graphs are the fallback, and otherwise a cross-check.

The background

Paul and Sarah Haines own Flat 33 Oslo Court, a first-floor flat in a seven-storey block of about 133 flats built around 1935. Their lease runs for 99 years from 25 December 1974. They claimed a statutory lease extension under the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993 [1].

The opening positions were far apart. The leaseholders' notice proposed a premium of £73,250. The landlord's counter-notice proposed £168,900 [1].

By the hearing, the gap had narrowed to two items: the freehold vacant possession value of the flat, and the value of the existing short lease. The First-tier Tribunal fixed the freehold value at £563,000, and nobody appealed that. The appeal was about the short lease value only.

Why relativity matters in a lease extension valuation

Under Schedule 13 to the 1993 Act, a leaseholder with fewer than 80 years left must pay the landlord half of the "marriage value" [2]. In simple terms, that is half of the uplift in value created by extending the lease.

To work out the uplift, the valuer needs the value of the flat on its existing short lease, assuming there were no right to extend. Real sales cannot give that figure directly, because every real buyer knows the right exists. So valuers express the short lease value as a percentage of the freehold value. That percentage is the relativity.

There are two main sources for it:

  • Market evidence, meaning actual sales of short leases, adjusted to strip out the value of the right to extend.
  • Relativity graphs, published by firms such as Savills and Gerald Eve, which plot relativity against years unexpired.

A lower relativity means a lower short lease value, a bigger uplift, and a higher premium. That is why landlords and leaseholders argue about it.

What the two valuers said

Item Landlord's valuer (Robin Sharp FRICS) Leaseholders' valuer (Steven Harding MRICS)
Method Average of the Savills 2016 graph (70.44%) and the Gerald Eve 2016 graph (70.02%) Four short-lease sales in the same block, weighted
Relativity 70.23% Not expressed as a graph figure
Short lease value £400,810 £400,000

The landlord's valuer thought three of the four sales were too dated to rely on. He did analyse one of them, the sale of Flat 22 Oslo Court, completed in May 2023 with 50.5 years unexpired, and found it showed a relativity of 83.06% [1].

Because the two end figures were so close, neither expert was cross-examined on short lease value. The tribunal was simply invited to choose between £400,000 and £400,810 [1].

What the First-tier Tribunal did

It chose neither. Saying it preferred a blended approach, it averaged the 83.06% from Flat 22 with the 70.23% from the graphs. That gave 76.65%, which it rounded to 77%. Applied to the freehold value, the short lease value became £433,510 and the premium £87,815 [1].

Why the Upper Tribunal overturned the relativity decision

Judge Elizabeth Cooke decided the appeal on written representations and allowed it on two grounds.

Procedural unfairness. If a tribunal is attracted to a solution that neither party has put forward, it must give the parties the chance to comment. Here the absence of cross-examination was crucial. The experts had not been tested on short lease value because nobody thought it was seriously in issue. The tribunal should have told the parties what it had in mind. That alone was enough to set the decision aside [1].

The method itself. The graphs are already averages drawn from many transactions and settlements. The judge put the objection in one sentence:

"To add in an isolated figure and re-average is to distort the graphs" [1]

She described adopting such a method without any expert support as unsatisfactory and irrational. The Upper Tribunal had already disapproved of averaging market evidence with graphs in Daejan Investments Ltd v Collins (2024) UKUT 26 (LC) [1].

The judge then substituted a short lease value of £400,000, the leaseholders' own market-based figure. Its closeness to the graph average suggested it was reliable. The parties agreed that this produced a premium of £104,570 [1].

The result in numbers

Item First-tier Tribunal Upper Tribunal
Freehold vacant possession value £563,000 £563,000
Short lease value £433,510 £400,000
Premium £87,815 £104,570

A change of about six percentage points in relativity moved the premium by £16,755.

Lessons for Notting Hill and Kensington leaseholders

Mansion blocks and converted houses across W11, W10, W2 and W8 contain many flats with leases in the 45 to 70 year range, where relativity has the largest effect on price.

  • Market evidence is best where it is available. Sales in the same block or street carry most weight. A valuer should say clearly how each sale has been adjusted and how much weight it has been given.
  • Graphs are a check, as well as a fallback. A relativity that sits well away from the graphs should prompt a second look. That point was also made in Deritend Investments (Birkdale) Ltd v Fung Tai Engineering Co Ltd (2025) UKUT 324 (LC), cited in this decision [1].
  • Do not leave a point untested because the figures are close. The experts here agreed within £810 and still ended up in the Upper Tribunal.
  • A tribunal can use its own expertise, but only fairly. If a panel floats a new approach at a hearing, the valuer or advocate should ask for the chance to respond to it.
  • Reform has not removed the issue. Until the valuation provisions of the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 are brought into force, marriage value and relativity remain part of every claim on a lease below 80 years.

The expert evidence angle

This was a case where the experts did much of what is asked of them. They narrowed the dispute, agreed what they could, and reached similar answers by different routes. The difficulty arose because that agreement meant the evidence was never tested, and the tribunal then went its own way.

For valuers, the practical point is to explain in the report why a method has been chosen and why the alternatives have been given less weight. If the tribunal is tempted to mix methods, the reasoning for not doing so is then already in writing.

Conclusion

Brickfield Properties v Haines confirms a simple order of preference in lease extension valuation: reliable market evidence first, graphs as the cross-check or the fallback, and no averaging of the two. It also confirms that a tribunal which departs from both experts must tell the parties first.

Leaseholders thinking about extending should get a valuation from a surveyor who works with relativity evidence regularly, ask what local short-lease sales exist, and ask how the proposed figure compares with the published graphs. Those answers show how well the valuation will stand up if the claim reaches a tribunal.

References

  1. Brickfield Properties Ltd v Haines (2026) UKUT 421 (LC), decision of 28 October 2026, Find Case Law, The National Archives. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
  2. Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993, Schedule 13, legislation.gov.uk. legislation.gov.uk.
Content Overview
Table of Contents
Search
Categories ----
Recent Post ----