Johnson (Valuation Officer) v Dune Group (2026) UKUT 446 (LC): Upper Tribunal Calls a Valuer’s Rental Analysis ‘Disappointing and Unsatisfactory’ in a Notting Dale W11 Office Valuation Dispute, Expert Witness Lessons (November 2026)

A valuation dispute about one office floor a short walk from Notting Hill has produced a useful lesson in how expert valuation evidence is tested. In Nicola Johnson v Dune Group Limited (2026) UKUT 446 (LC), decided on 18 November 2026, the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) allowed the Valuation Officer's appeal on the rateable value of the fourth floor of The White Building, 1 Breaker's Place, London W11. The appeal was unopposed. Even so, the Tribunal did not simply adopt the winning side's expert evidence. It criticised parts of it, rejected several comparables and substituted its own figures.

For anyone who commissions or gives expert valuation evidence, on business rates, lease renewals, rent reviews or Red Book valuations for litigation, the reasoning matters more than the result.

The property and the dispute

The White Building is a modern seven-storey office building, built in 2008, in the Notting Dale W11 office campus near Latimer Road station and the Westfield centre. The fourth floor has an agreed net internal area of 1,144 square metres.

The floor was let on a ten-year lease from 24 September 2021 at a commencing rent of £430,815 a year, with 14 months rent free and a further 12 months if the tenant did not operate its year-five break. It was handed over in Category A condition: a finished shell with services and lighting but without the tenant's own fit-out. The tenant then carried out Category B works, including partitioning and fittings.

The 2023 rating list showed a rateable value of £490,000. The Valuation Officer reduced that to £427,500 on challenge. The Valuation Tribunal for England then reduced it again to £362,500 in a decision handed down on 11 March 2026. The Valuation Officer appealed.

It was common ground that the assessment should include an uplift for the tenant's Category B fit-out. The argument was about how much, and about the Category A rent to which the uplift is added. The valuation date was 1 April 2021.

What the Tribunal decided

The decision was given by Mr Mark Higgin FRICS FIRRV, who inspected the property on 6 October 2026. He found:

  • a Category A rental value of £322 per square metre;
  • a Category B uplift of £75.11 per square metre;
  • a combined value of £397 per square metre, producing £454,168, rounded to £454,000.

Because no proposal had been made to increase the assessment above the challenged figure, the rateable value was determined at £427,500. The Valuation Tribunal's £362,500 was set aside.

The Tribunal noted that this was the fifth Upper Tribunal case since 2023 on Category B values and the first on the 2023 rating list.

How the expert evidence fared

Only the Valuation Officer called evidence: a chartered surveyor on valuation and a chartered quantity surveyor on fit-out costs. With no opposing expert and no cross-examination from the ratepayer, their evidence might have been expected to pass unchallenged. It did not.

The Category A rent

The valuation expert analysed the subject letting at about £288 per square metre, using a 6.5% yield to spread rent-free periods across the lease. The Tribunal recorded that he could not point to anything empirical to support 6.5%. The market reports he mentioned were not in evidence. He had made no adjustment for market movement between the valuation date and the start of the lease.

He relied on five comparable lettings, with analysed rents ranging from about £288 to £481 per square metre. The Tribunal said the detail provided was limited and described that as "disappointing and unsatisfactory". It set aside the two earliest lettings as outliers, treated the subject property's own rent, agreed about six months after the valuation date, as an anomaly, and took £322 per square metre from a single comparable let on 25 March 2021.

The fit-out costs

The quantity surveyor analysed the contractor's final account of £843,484, adjusted it to £795,147 at the valuation date, and attributed £743,849 to Category B works. The Tribunal found that neither expert had separated rateable fitting-out from items better described as furniture, such as racks and illuminated display cases. It did that exercise itself and arrived at £685,913, or about £600 per square metre.

Her cross-checks against published cost guides carried little weight, because she could not say whether the published rates covered Category A works, Category B works or both. A comparison with three other fit-outs was found to be of little use because the indexation was unclear.

Turning cost into rent

The valuation expert amortised the fit-out cost at both 4.5% and 6.5% and preferred the higher rate, producing £94 per square metre. The Tribunal said it was not entirely clear why an investor's yield had been used instead of a borrowing rate, when earlier Tribunal authority had treated 4.5% as reasonable. It amortised its own cost figure at 4.5% over the full lease term, because the break had not been operated, and reached £75.11.

Expert witness lessons for valuers

Unopposed does not mean unexamined. A specialist tribunal will test the evidence itself. Every input in the valuation has to stand on its own.

Evidence every rate. If a yield, discount rate or amortisation rate is used, the report should show where it comes from, and the source should be exhibited. A reference to a market report that is not in the bundle proves nothing.

Give full detail on comparables. For each one, state the date, lease terms, incentives, break options, condition at letting and how the headline rent was analysed. A list of addresses and figures is not analysis.

Be careful with evidence after the valuation date. The Tribunal treated the subject property's own letting, agreed after the valuation date, as an anomaly and declined to start from it.

Stay within your expertise and say where it stops. The costs expert had not previously advised on office fit-outs. That did not disqualify her, but the gaps in her cross-checks showed.

Apportion costs properly. Where a valuation depends on the cost of works, separate what forms part of the property from what is furniture or trade fittings. If the experts do not, the tribunal will.

Follow the authorities or explain why not. If earlier decisions point to a method or a rate, an expert who departs from them needs to give reasons.

What this means for Notting Hill and W11 owners and occupiers

The same discipline applies wherever a valuation is likely to be contested in west London:

  • office and retail occupiers challenging rateable values after a fit-out;
  • landlords and tenants at rent review or lease renewal, where improvements and fit-out are disregarded or rentalised;
  • leasehold enfranchisement and lease extension claims, where tenant's improvements must be valued out;
  • matrimonial, probate and tax valuations that may end up before a court or tribunal.

In each of these, the valuation that survives is the one whose comparables, adjustments and rates can be traced to evidence.

How Notting Hill Surveyors can help

Our chartered surveyors prepare Red Book valuations and expert reports for properties across Notting Hill, Holland Park, North Kensington and the wider W10 and W11 area. If a valuation is in dispute, or likely to be, we can advise on the evidence needed before positions are fixed.

Frequently asked questions

What was the outcome in Johnson v Dune Group?

The Upper Tribunal allowed the Valuation Officer's appeal on 18 November 2026 and determined the rateable value of the fourth floor of The White Building at £427,500, replacing the Valuation Tribunal's £362,500.

What is the difference between Category A and Category B fit-out?

Category A is the landlord's basic finish, such as services, lighting and floors. Category B is the occupier's own fit-out, such as partitions, meeting rooms and fittings. In rating, Category B works that form part of the property can add to its rateable value.

Why did the Tribunal criticise the expert evidence?

The valuation expert could not support his 6.5% yield with evidence, and his analysis of comparable lettings lacked detail. Neither expert separated rateable fit-out costs from furniture-type items.

Does this decision affect residential valuations?

Not directly. But the Tribunal's approach to comparables, unsupported rates and evidence after the valuation date applies to any expert valuation that may be tested in a court or tribunal.

This article is a general summary of a published decision for information only. It is not legal or valuation advice.

Content Overview
Table of Contents
Search
Categories ----
Recent Post ----