One percentage point on a single rate can more than halve part of a lease extension premium. That rate, the deferment rate, has been the subject of a government consultation that closed on 21 October 2026, and no decision has yet been announced. For anyone commissioning a lease extension valuation in Notting Hill this winter, the question is how to act while the answer is pending.
Key Takeaways
- The government's consultation on leasehold enfranchisement valuation rates opened on 15 July 2026 and closed on 21 October 2026. Responses are being analysed.
- It covers the two rates that drive premiums: the deferment rate and the capitalisation rate.
- The valuation reforms in the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 are not yet in force.
- Until they are, premiums are set under the existing law, with rates argued by valuers and decided by the tribunal where the parties cannot agree.
- Higher rates generally mean lower premiums for leaseholders.
Where things stand in November 2026
The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government published its consultation, "Leasehold enfranchisement valuation rates", on 15 July 2026. On 7 September it extended the deadline by four weeks. The consultation closed at 11:59pm on 21 October 2026. The government says it is analysing the feedback, and no outcome has been published.
The consultation asks whether, and how, the Secretary of State should use powers in the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 to prescribe the deferment and capitalisation rates.
The wider valuation reforms in the 2024 Act are not yet in force. They include:
- A standard valuation method.
- Extensions of 990 years at a peppercorn rent.
- Removal of marriage value.
- A general cap on the ground rent used in the calculation at 0.1% of the freehold value with vacant possession.
The government won a High Court challenge to the Act brought by freeholders, and that decision is under appeal.
How a lease extension premium is built
Under the current law, a flat lease extension premium has up to three parts.
| Part | What it pays for | Rate that drives it |
|---|---|---|
| Term | The ground rent the freeholder loses | Capitalisation rate |
| Reversion | The delay before the freeholder gets the flat back | Deferment rate |
| Marriage value | A share of the uplift from extending, where the lease is 80 years or less | Relativity |
The valuer needs the value of the flat on a long lease, the value on the existing lease, the ground rent terms, and the two rates.
What the consultation said about the rates
Deferment rate
Since the Sportelli litigation, the benchmark has been 4.75% for houses and 5% for flats. The consultation set out options prepared with the Government Actuary's Department. As reported, these ranged from 1.61%, a mechanical update that the actuaries advised against using alone, to 6.05% for houses and 6.3% for flats. Other approaches gave 5.05% and 5.85% for houses.
The government is considering keeping the Sportelli rates, updating them, or adopting another method.
Capitalisation rate
The consultation reviewed tribunal decisions. Rates ranged from 4.5% to 9%, with 88% falling between 6% and 7%, and a mean and median of about 6.5%. Options include one rate for all ground rents, or three rates depending on whether the rent is fixed, rises by fixed steps, or is linked to inflation.
Why it matters: an illustration
Commentary on the consultation gave a worked example. For a £250,000 flat with 100 years left, the illustrative premium is £4,576 at a 6% capitalisation rate and a 5% deferment rate. Raising the deferment rate to 6% cuts the reversion from about £1,901 to £737.
With 80 years left, the reversion falls from about £5,044 at 5% to £2,363 at 6%.
Separately, the government plans to cap most residential ground rents at £250 a year, falling to a peppercorn after 40 years. That is the subject of a different consultation.
What this means for a lease extension valuation in Notting Hill
Notting Hill, Holland Park and Bayswater are dominated by stucco-fronted houses converted into flats, and by mansion blocks. Many leases were granted for 99 or 125 years and now have between 60 and 90 years left. Several features of this market sharpen the effect of the rates.
- High values magnify small changes. The reversion is a function of the flat's long-lease value. The higher the value, the more each fraction of a percentage point is worth.
- Leases near 80 years. Once a lease drops to 80 years, marriage value applies under the current law. Waiting for reform risks crossing that line.
- Escalating ground rents. Leases with doubling or reviewed ground rents make the capitalisation rate and the 0.1% cap far more significant.
- Individual properties. A first-floor flat with a balcony onto a garden square is not comparable with a lower ground floor flat. Valuers must adjust carefully.
Extend now or wait?
There is no single answer. The points to weigh are:
- Lease length. Above 85 years with a low ground rent, the premium is modest and the case for waiting is weaker than it sounds.
- Approaching 80 years. Delay risks adding marriage value if reform does not arrive in time.
- Sale or remortgage plans. A short lease can limit lending now.
- Uncertainty. There is no commencement date for the valuation reforms, and the rates are undecided.
A valuer can run the figures both ways so the decision rests on numbers.
Expert evidence: how disputed premiums are decided
Most lease extensions are agreed between valuers. Where they are not, either side can apply to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) to determine the premium.
At the tribunal, each party's valuer usually gives expert evidence. The tribunal is a specialist body, often including a valuer member, and it expects:
- Independence. The expert's duty is to the tribunal, even though the same valuer may have negotiated for the client earlier.
- Transparent comparables. Each sale relied on, with adjustments for time, lease length, floor, condition and improvements shown.
- Reasoned rates. A departure from the established deferment rate needs evidence. So does the choice of capitalisation rate.
- A joint statement. The valuers are expected to agree what they can and list what remains in dispute.
A valuer who negotiates and then gives evidence must keep the roles apart. The RICS expert witness standard, 5th edition, which takes effect on 30 November 2026, restricts acting as both advocate and expert and requires assumptions and alternative conclusions to be set out.
Where the difference between the parties is small, a single joint expert valuer, instructed by both, can be a proportionate way to settle the figure without a hearing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Has the government decided the new deferment rate?
No. The consultation closed on 21 October 2026 and the outcome has not been published.
Is marriage value still payable?
Yes, under the current law, where the lease has 80 years or less remaining. Its removal under the 2024 Act is not yet in force.
Who decides the premium if the freeholder and leaseholder disagree?
The First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber), on expert valuation evidence.
Will higher rates reduce my premium?
Generally, yes. A higher deferment or capitalisation rate produces a lower figure for the freeholder's interest.
Conclusion
The rates that decide lease extension premiums are under review but unchanged. Leaseholders with leases close to 80 years, or with rising ground rents, should take valuation advice now and not assume reform will arrive in time. Freeholders should expect closer scrutiny of the rates their valuers adopt.
Notting Hill Surveyors provides lease extension and enfranchisement valuations across W11, W2 and W8, and gives expert valuation evidence to the First-tier Tribunal.